930 Forums
=> GENERAL DISCUSSION => Topic started by: Charlie Nakatestes, Japanese Golfer on June 20, 2003, 03:50:00 pm
-
I noticed that Good Charlotte was on the cover of Teen People with the headline "Good Charlotte's Girl Troubles." Didn't have time to read the article, as it was my turn at the checkout. I know some of y'all know these guys rather intimately. Can someone fill me in on the details of their problems?
-
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&safe=off&q=good+charlotte+girl+troubles (http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&safe=off&q=good+charlotte+girl+troubles)
-
so the boys are from waldorf? i didnt know them- i guess they werent that special
-
I went to school with them from 6th-12th.
Blah blah blah.
-
Did they have girl trouble back then?
The graduated from high school? That's not very punk rock.
Originally posted by chavah79:
I went to school with them from 6th-12th.
Blah blah blah.
-
Where's BeNjIJoelOliCoUs (ouch that hurt to type) when you need her? LOL
MindCage
Mindless Faith (http://www.mindlessfaith.com)
Deep6 Productions (http://www.deep6.com)
-
Originally posted by MindCage:
Where's BeNjIJoelOliCoUs (ouch that hurt to type) when you need her? LOL
MindCage
Mindless Faith (http://www.mindlessfaith.com)
Deep6 Productions (http://www.deep6.com)
Stalking the band?
-
Originally posted by Rhett Miller:
Did they have girl trouble back then?
The graduated from high school? That's not very punk rock.
From what I can remember, they didn't have troubles with much of anything. Pretty popular kids, actually. Of course they'd like you to think that they were abused and misused now...but I remember who the unpopular kids were and it wasn't them.
Would them being uber-Christians/Young Lifers also detract from their Punk Rockness? ;)
-
Originally posted by chavah79:
Originally posted by Rhett Miller:
Did they have girl trouble back then?
The graduated from high school? That's not very punk rock.
From what I can remember, they didn't have troubles with much of anything. Pretty popular kids, actually. Of course they'd like you to think that they were abused and misused now...but I remember who the unpopular kids were and it wasn't them.
Would them being uber-Christians/Young Lifers also detract from their Punk Rockness? ;) [/b]
I can vouch for thier un-punk rock ways first hand as well.
I'll give one example: is going to the hairdreser to dye your hair orange punk rock? I didnt think so :eek:
-
Originally posted by chavah79:
Originally posted by Rhett Miller:
Did they have girl trouble back then?
The graduated from high school? That's not very punk rock.
From what I can remember, they didn't have troubles with much of anything. Pretty popular kids, actually. Of course they'd like you to think that they were abused and misused now...but I remember who the unpopular kids were and it wasn't them.
Would them being uber-Christians/Young Lifers also detract from their Punk Rockness? ;) [/b]
It'd be really nice if the Post did a big article tearing them a new one for being complete fakes, but they already have a show on MTV, so I guess cred isn't really an issue for them anymore.
-
I thought on a thread a while ago it was decided that no one could poke fun at Good Charlotte......
-
It was.
And for the record, I didn't start the thread in gopes of poking fun of them. I want to know about their girl troubles.
Originally posted by keithstg:
I thought on a thread a while ago it was decided that no one could poke fun at Good Charlotte......
-
Originally posted by Rhett Miller:
It was.
And for the record, I didn't start the thread in gopes of poking fun of them. I want to know about their girl troubles.
Originally posted by keithstg:
I thought on a thread a while ago it was decided that no one could poke fun at Good Charlotte......
[/b]
I know you didn't. I just seems to come about naturally....
-
Originally posted by Rhett Miller:
It was.
And for the record, I didn't start the thread in gopes of poking fun of them. I want to know about their girl troubles.
not that i think you really care, but just to humor the question:
joel is engaged, billy has a longtime girlfriend, paul has been seeing the same girl for a while, chris has a girlfriend, and i'm pretty sure benji is single now.
in other words, don't believe everything you see in teen people. that should come as a surprise to noone.
-
some people have a good reason not to like them. Do you ever wonder why not much of the local music scene supports them? I mean, we know HFS does, but they would support Satan for money and listeners. But when is the last time GC has played a special show just for DC/Baltimore/Waldorf? I know a band from Boston like this....Godsmack.
-
Originally posted by sonickteam2:
some people have a good reason not to like them. Do you ever wonder why not much of the local music scene supports them? I mean, we know HFS does, but they would support Satan for money and listeners. But when is the last time GC has played a special show just for DC/Baltimore/Waldorf? I know a band from Boston like this....Godsmack.
Didnt they play a special cd release show or something at 9:30 last year?
-
Originally posted by jadetree:
Didnt they play a special cd release show or something at 9:30 last year?
yes. the dc show was the day the album was released. they then played special shows in philly, ny, and la.
-
Who is noone? Peter Noone? Are you saying that a magazine would make things up?
Originally posted by thatguy:
Originally posted by Rhett Miller:
It was.
And for the record, I didn't start the thread in gopes of poking fun of them. I want to know about their girl troubles.
not that i think you really care, but just to humor the question:
joel is engaged, billy has a longtime girlfriend, paul has been seeing the same girl for a while, chris has a girlfriend, and i'm pretty sure benji is single now.
in other words, don't believe everything you see in teen people. that should come as a surprise to noone. [/b]
-
Originally posted by thatguy:
joel is engaged, billy has a longtime girlfriend, paul has been seeing the same girl for a while, chris has a girlfriend, and i'm pretty sure benji is single now.
in other words, don't believe everything you see in teen people. that should come as a surprise to noone.
Benji is single and last I heard he had the drama of getting piss off phone calls from one "rockstar" female because he was talking to Christina Aguleria... LOL Even rockstars have drama too!
MindCage
Mindless Faith (http://www.mindlessfaith.com)
Deep6 Productions (http://www.deep6.com)
-
Originally posted by thatguy:
Originally posted by jadetree:
Didnt they play a special cd release show or something at 9:30 last year?
yes. the dc show was the day the album was released. they then played special shows in philly, ny, and la. [/b]
Doesnt sound so special anymore then does it?
-
Why would he want to talk to Christine Agulera? She doesn't seem all that bright.
Originally posted by MindCage:
Originally posted by thatguy:
joel is engaged, billy has a longtime girlfriend, paul has been seeing the same girl for a while, chris has a girlfriend, and i'm pretty sure benji is single now.
in other words, don't believe everything you see in teen people. that should come as a surprise to noone.
Benji is single and last I heard he had the drama of getting piss off phone calls from one "rockstar" female because he was talking to Christina Aguleria... LOL Even rockstars have drama too!
MindCage
Mindless Faith (http://www.mindlessfaith.com)
Deep6 Productions (http://www.deep6.com) [/b]
-
Originally posted by sonickteam2:
some people have a good reason not to like them. Do you ever wonder why not much of the local music scene supports them? I mean, we know HFS does, but they would support Satan for money and listeners. But when is the last time GC has played a special show just for DC/Baltimore/Waldorf? I know a band from Boston like this....Godsmack.
I have been to a few "package" type shows like Warped where they got booed unmercifully. At one point they looked they were about to cry. They may be nice guys but it doesnt mean that anyone not female and 16 doesnt see through them. Its weak music made by poseurs.. I realize they may have some friends on the board, but that is my opinion and im sticking with it..
-
Originally posted by Metal Meltdown:
I have been to a few "package" type shows like Warped where they got booed unmercifully. At one point they looked they were about to cry. They may be nice guys but it doesnt mean that anyone not female and 16 doesnt see through them. Its weak music made by poseurs.. I realize they may have some friends on the board, but that is my opinion and im sticking with it..
The real problem with the band isn't even that they're fake. That's fine. It's that they're the only band from around here who seems to get national attention . . . and they're fake. We've got one of the greatest record labels around, and although Dischord was never in it to get fame and fortune, it'd be nice if they got even a teensy bit of the publicity that gets wasted on GC. They're fame hurts DC/Balt more than it helps.
-
I dunno...Dischord seems to get quite a bit of attention, and all of it is positive, downright worshipful.
Originally posted by mjnova:
Originally posted by Metal Meltdown:
I have been to a few "package" type shows like Warped where they got booed unmercifully. At one point they looked they were about to cry. They may be nice guys but it doesnt mean that anyone not female and 16 doesnt see through them. Its weak music made by poseurs.. I realize they may have some friends on the board, but that is my opinion and im sticking with it..
The real problem with the band isn't even that they're fake. That's fine. It's that they're the only band from around here who seems to get national attention . . . and they're fake. We've got one of the greatest record labels around, and although Dischord was never in it to get fame and fortune, it'd be nice if they got even a teensy bit of the publicity that gets wasted on GC. They're fame hurts DC/Balt more than it helps. [/b]
-
What do y'all mean when you say Good Charlotte is "fake"?
Do they not actually perform their music, ala Milli Vanilli?
-
dude who thinks these guys are hott?
NOT!
-
Well, they are fake in the sense that they claim to have had such a horrible time in school, that they were the "losers", blah blah blah...when if you ask people who went to school with them, it couldn't be farther from the truth.
Or then again, maybe the people they went to school with--myself included--are biased. Everyone thinks they had it bad in high school.
*shrugs*
(I should really post on some other topics or else everyone is going to think I'm here just to bash GC! I just usually don't think I have anything insightful to add to the other convos)
-
Originally posted by chavah79:
(I should really post on some other topics or else everyone is going to think I'm here just to bash GC! I just usually don't think I have anything insightful to add to the other convos)
I thought you were a spurned GC groupie....
which one do you love most? Benji is such a dreamboat.
-
I don't beleve that there is such a thing as 'fake' in music. I do beleve that there is such a thing a good. GC is not good, but that never stopped anyone from selling records. I just wish that they would sell advertising space on their untattooed body parts so we could get this whold punk rock nonsence over with. Infact, if your the front person of a band, I highly recommend getting a Mountan Dew tattoo on your forhead as a proactive messure, for the punk rock band of the future will be messured by the power of their sellout.
-
Originally posted by Shoddywork:
I don't beleve that there is such a thing as 'fake' in music. I do beleve that there is such a thing a good. GC is not good, but that never stopped anyone from selling records. I just wish that they would sell advertising space on their untattooed body parts so we could get this whold punk rock nonsence over with. Infact, if your the front person of a band, I highly recommend getting a Mountan Dew tattoo on your forhead as a proactive messure, for the punk rock band of the future will be messured by the power of their sellout.
Although it's mostly BS, the punk scene was built in some sense on authenticity. Definit it is hard, but to paraphrase that old Supreme Court Ruling on smut, "I'll know it when I don't see it". And they just give off this real obvious impression of doing anything to further their career. I remember seeing an add for one of their tours with the band standing next to a Honda or some other car that was sponsoring their tour. There's nothing wrong with selling out, but you can't have it both ways. Either you're still part of the "scene" or "community" or you're a big rock star.
-
Originally posted by mjnova:
Originally posted by Shoddywork:
I don't beleve that there is such a thing as 'fake' in music. I do beleve that there is such a thing a good. GC is not good, but that never stopped anyone from selling records. I just wish that they would sell advertising space on their untattooed body parts so we could get this whold punk rock nonsence over with. Infact, if your the front person of a band, I highly recommend getting a Mountan Dew tattoo on your forhead as a proactive messure, for the punk rock band of the future will be messured by the power of their sellout.
Although it's mostly BS, the punk scene was built in some sense on authenticity. Definit it is hard, but to paraphrase that old Supreme Court Ruling on smut, "I'll know it when I don't see it". And they just give off this real obvious impression of doing anything to further their career. I remember seeing an add for one of their tours with the band standing next to a Honda or some other car that was sponsoring their tour. There's nothing wrong with selling out, but you can't have it both ways. Either you're still part of the "scene" or "community" or you're a big rock star. [/b]
I supose the problem I have with punk was the whole "Lets all be non-conformists together" vibe I got from the sceen, when I was younger and cared about these things. And I find myself scared of any band that calls themself's punk. But, then again I don't have the same fear if a band calls themself's bluegrass, so perhaps it's just because I grew up lissening to punk rock and don't like to see the music of my youth becoming another predictable catagory.
-
Are Good Charlotte really Christian rock? Eww.
-
From what I can tell, Nickel Creek is the Good Charlotte of bluegrass.