I thought this was a fantastic show! Band of Horses far exceeded my expectations. It certainly helped that the audience was really into their performance, which resulted in a feedback loop with the band. They seemed to be enjoying themselves just as much as the audience around me.
I only got there in time to see the last two songs of A Decent Animal's set. They sounded pretty good with lots of good energy. The crowd seemed to enjoy them.
The audience was almost completely dead for Love As Laughter though. I didn't care for them at first either. The lead singer screamed through most of their first two songs instead of singing. His vocals were pretty week, but I eventually came to appreciate a certain Dylan-esque quality to his vocals on some of their better songs. Their instrument playing are what really won me over though. Their drummer was fabulous, the bassist was excellent, and the lead singer's guitar playing was very good. When a couple BOH guys played with them on several songs, they sounded pretty good. The crowd didn't seem to appreciate it though, which had me worried about their reaction to BOH's set, but my worries were ultimately unfounded.