Hmmm, seems to be a pretty divided group here. Tilly's sugary pop is not for everyone, but if you like the group sounds heard in bands like Architecture in Helsinki or even the Polyphonic Spree, you may very well like these guys.
I am neither a drama nerd or a Saddle Creek hanger-on. I just like catchy pop songs, and this band has plenty of those. However simple, I kind of like it that way. Plus, they actually look like they have a good time on stage, and so few bands even try to go through that motion lately. That goes a long way.