First time I heard them was when they opened for Doves and they were amazing. I went home thinking they sounded like The Replacements (which sounds stupid, but they were much more all-over-the-place and raw), but was bewildered by the lo-fi sound of The Modern Age ep I picked up at the show. Then saw them again six months later when they headlined the 9:30, after the album came out, and by then it seemed liked they'd settled into their stand-still-and-deliver-the-songs routine. It was only okay.