October 6, 2004
ROCK REVIEW | THE KILLERS
Starting With Indie, Looking to Move On
By BEN RATLIFF
The New York Times
Any popular music that begins in slyness or in jest will end in a straight face. The Killers, a young band from Las Vegas who sold out two shows at Irving Plaza this week, are students of the early-1980's New Wave revival and won't rest until they know all the declensions and multiplication tables. They're dealing with a language of foppish moans and echoey guitar and synthesizer lines; they are inflating and popularizing these elements, through steady rat-a-tat eighth notes, into something as expansive as skywriting and rigid as a Mass.
At least that's how they're choosing to reach audiences in their own country. The band's first album, "Hot Fuss" (Island), was released with different songs in Britain and America. On the British version there's a song called "Indie Rock & Roll," and it might be the Killers' best work: it sounds like an anthem and works along less forthright lyrical lines, lining up disconnected glimpses of an indie-rock fan's frumpy but passionate life. When the band played it at Irving Plaza on Monday, they broke out of the sackcloth-and-ashes mode: the singer Brandon Flowers, buffered from contemporaneity by a waistcoat, tie and floppy haircut, began to let himself go. "Indie rock & roll is in my soul," he sang and shouted. "It's what I need." He was transmitting sincerity and self-mockery at the same time.
Clearly the Killers are obsessed with the notion of indie rock. But it's a particular kind: frequently they sound like idiosyncratic bands that had brief moments of true popularity in America, like the Psychedelic Furs, New Order and Big Country, among others. This band doesn't want to remain indie rockers; they want to have started out that way. With songs of jealousy and stolen girlfriends, like "Mr. Brightside" and "Smile Like You Mean It," filled with heavy and simple melodic hooks and a huge sound, they're shortening the aesthetic distance between indie-rock cabalism and mass audiences.