"Hey Now Now," such a very Markie song....
I'm in a similar boat (not the same, just similar) as I've been largely unimpressed this year. For some reason I've gotten very few new albums -- I think the lack of inspiration has kept me from testing out a bunch of those I've heard about.
I do really like the new Decemberists, Brendan Benson, Sleater Kinney, Ok Go (which I understand has limited appeal).
Other albums I like (QOTSA, New Pornographers, The National, Idlewild) but am not dazzled by.
But I've completely missed (i.e., not heard) a lot of the albums folks are putting on their year end best of lists: Sufjan, Architecture in Helsinki, Clap Your Hands or Say Hi to Your Mom, Josh Rouse, 2nd Franz Ferdinand, Hold Steady, Shout Out Louds, Hot Hot Heat, Low, new Of Montreal, (I'm still waiting for The Oranges Band), Pernice Brothers, etc...