Posted on Sun, Feb. 23, 2003
The State.com
Best New Artist? It could be a curse
Damien McCaffery got it right in the current issue of Vibe.
In a piece titled "The Grammy Whammy," the associate editor went back in time and dissected the list of "best new artist" Grammy winners to determine whether the award was a blessing or a curse for the recipient.
Here's how McCaffery rated 10 former winners:
1990: Mariah Carey beat the Black Crowes, Kentucky Headhunters, Lisa Stanfield and Wilson Phillips. McCaffery's verdict: Blessing. "Carey's next nine records went platinum," he wrote.
1991: Memphis-based singer John Cohn beat Boyz II Men, C+C Music Factory, Color Me Badd and Seal. The verdict: Curse. "Cohn came from nowhere, grabbed the BNA and rapidly returned to nowhere."
1992: Hip-hop group Arrested Development beat Billy Ray Cyrus, Sophie B. Hawkins, Kris Kross and Jon Secada. The verdict: Curse. Their debut, "â??'3 years, 5 Months, and 2 Days in the Life of â??.â??.â??.' predicted the duration of our tolerance," McCaffery wrote.
1993: R&B singer Toni Braxton beat Belly, Blind Melon, Digable Planets and SWV. The verdict: Blessing. "After her self-titled debut, Braxton kept scoring with progressively sexier, cattier songs."
1994: Sheryl Crow beat Ace of Base, Counting Crows, Crash Test Dummies and Green Day. The verdict: Blessing. "Her follow-up (albums) sold well."
1995: S.C. pop-rock band Hootie and the Blowfish beat Brandy, Alanis Morissette, Joan Osborne and Shania Twain. The verdict: Curse. "After their 14-times platinum debut, 'Cracked Rear View,' album sales in '96, '98 and 2000 proved we were hootied out."
1996: Country singer Leann Rimes beat Garbage, Jewel, No Doubt, and the Tony Rich Project. The verdict: Blessing. "Rimes hit it big at 14 with 'Blue.' Two follow-ups also went multiplatinum."
1997: Pop singer Paula Cole beat Fiona Apple, Erykah Badu, Hanson and Puff Daddy. The verdict: Curse. "The swift demise of her 1999 CD answered the question 'Where Have All the Cowboys Gone?' By then, we were gettin' freaky with Barenaked Ladies."
1998: Lauryn Hill beat Backstreet Boys, Andrea Bocelli, Dixie Chicks and Natalie Imbruglia. The verdict: Blessing and Curse. "Hill's solo debut was a critical and commercial hit, but the stress of representing for all conscious sisters who look hot got to her."
1999: Pop diva Christina Aguilera beat Macy Gray, Kid Rock, Britney Spears and Susan Tedeschi. The verdict: Blessing. "Shockingly, judges chose the 'Teen Sexpot Who Could Actually Sing.'â??"