I find that Paste is more critical then most in its reviews, most albums get three stars reviews and below. Which is good because it makes want to read the four star reviews as potential things worth looking into further. I found out about Van Hunt that way...
And if they came the IV Thieves a 1.5 I can only imagine how the Driveblind record will be received, I suspect several pitchforks will be sharpened over that one. It wont me make enjoy the band less, just might me less likely to cheerlead for them.