American Idol - final 8

[Vas Deferens]

Who will be kicked out tonight? I'm betting on Haley or Phil...
 
 Sanjaya actually did good last night and picked the best song of the evening. The rest of the contestants picked your normal commercial crap. They should do an indie night one of these days!

[Bombay Chutney]

Originally posted by Joe Marshmallow III:
   They should do an indie night one of these days!

I want an all-Morrissey night.

[vansmack]

They were all out of their genre last night and it made the entertainment far worse than usual.
 
 I agree that either Phil or Haley (likely Haley) is gone tonight, but nobody deserved to survive after last night.  I'm still not sure why you would ask 8 American Idols to do a Latin Themed night, but that's just me.

[eros]

It's still not as bad as country night.

[vansmack]

Originally posted by eros:
  It's still not as bad as country night.

I thought that at least one or two were comfortable on Country night last year (Kelly Pickler, Chris Duaghtry, etc.).
 
 Last night, they were all trainwrecks.

[eros]

Originally posted by vansmack:
   

Originally posted by eros:
  It's still not as bad as country night.

I thought that at least one or two were comfortable on Country night last year (Kelly Pickler, Chris Duaghtry, etc.).
 
 Last night, they were all trainwrecks. [/b]

True.  There are still usually a few countrified contestants left at this point (none this year that I can tell).  I just meant Latin night is personally less painful for me to sit through than country night (though it's a very close call).

[sonickteam2]

this is the most "un-indie" thread this bored has ever witnessed.

[Guiny]

I thought Blake sounded the best and Sanjaya was once again, the worst.

[Vas Deferens]

Chris Richardson has the most annoying voice. His nose is actually doing the singing  

[vansmack]

Originally posted by le sonick:
  this is the most "un-indie" thread this bored has ever witnessed.

When did this become an indie board?

[sonickteam2]

Originally posted by vansmack:
   

Originally posted by le sonick:
  this is the most "un-indie" thread this bored has ever witnessed.

When did this become an indie board? [/b]

i wasnt the one who requested "indie night" on american idol.

[beetsnotbeats]

Originally posted by Joe Marshmallow III:
  They should do an indie night one of these days!

Who should be the mentor?

[vansmack]

Originally posted by beetsnotbeats:
  Who should be the mentor?

They would probably choose someone like Ben Gibbard.
 
 I would choose Frank Black.

[Vas Deferens]

Hmmm, tough one.
 
 Maybe Henry Rollins for hardcore indie night.

[beetsnotbeats]

Courtney Love