MS..why have though foresaken me? Again!? So Microsoft has an uncanny ability to develop really great products and not tell anyone about them ?? including their own developers. There??s no one common goal to meet one great strategy like Apple does. I made a joke earlier today about Apple releasing new iTunes software in conjunction with their new phone. If it were Microsoft and they had a new phone that only worked with WMP 12, they wouldn??t talk to WMP12 to see when it was done before releasing the phone.
I mentioned earlier that the Xbox 360 can see computers on the network and play their files. If those computers are media center computers, the experience is much better (one that even Smackette will use). Well, the server experience leaves much to be desired.
For example. MS uses a program called Media Connect to connect your computer to a media extender. A computer that includes Media Center is essentially an overlay to improve the Media Connect experience as illustrated below:
Media Connect w/out Media Center <img src="http://www.winsupersite.com/images/reviews/xbox360_dm_11.jpg" alt=" - " />
Media Center XP <img src="http://www.xbox.com/NR/rdonlyres/3B424750-1210-4129-9819-B995D7C38547/0/MyMusicLibrary001.jpg" alt=" - " />
Media Center Vista <img src="http://www.gadgets-reviews.com/uimg_new/microsoft-debuts-extenders-for-windows-media-center-adds-divx-and-xvid.jpg" alt=" - " />
The Media Center experience is obviously much easier and more friendly to use, simply because it uses metadata (and the search function is really nice).
Media Connect has been through many iterations. The original is obsolete and was replaced by 2.0 with WMP9. If you install Windows Media Player 11 on XP, it comes with Media Connect 3.0. If you install WMP 11 on Vista, you get Media Connect 4.0. Fear not, I??m shaking my head with you.
Guess which version comes on the Home Server? 2.0! Why? The WHS was built on the Windows 2003 server platform and there is no windows media player beyond 9.0 built for the server. That means no upgrades for Media Connect because it??s built around WMP.
In addition, the Media Center Overlay (the fancy user experience) is not available as an add-in. It only comes with the purchase of an operating system that has hardware that supports certain elements ?? whether you use them or not. You cannot purchase it separately, even if you own an Xbox 360 that
does have the hardware support!
So what does this mean for your experience? Well, it all depends on what you use. If you only have iTunes or Winamp or WMP and no extender, absolutely nothing. If you hook your computer up directly to your TV? Again, nothing.
If you have an extender that has a very nice built in overlay, the only problem may be file support (MC 2.0 does not support Xvid and DivX for example, but perhaps your extender does).
If you have an Xbox 360 (built by MS) and a WHS (built buy MS) then you??re totally bummed. Let??s start at the most basic: want to find ??The Beatles? ?? better head to the ??T?s, cause you ain??t gonna find them in the ??B?s. MC 2.0 can??t strip ??the? from the database! I know, it's 2008. It's disgusting.
File types are just as ridiculous. I can??t play, for example, WMP11 (or even 10) videos on my 360 using an XP machine or the WHS. There??s absolutely no excuse for this. Xvid and DivX? Forget about it. Crazily enough, if I copy the Xvid or divX movie to a USB flash drive and plug it in the 360, the 360 can play it. At this point I hope you??re not shaking your head but pounding it on your desk like I am.
This is why Apple will continue to kick MS??s ass. Even if MS can beat Apple to the market with a home server, Apple has 6-12 months to release a perfect product while MS gets beaten up on the blogs - and deservedly so. One hand does not talk to the other - it's as if they don't use any of their products in the real world!
Now, there??s big hype about
MS??s ??Fiji? project. The details have been very tight lipped, but let??s hope that by the end of the summer, they get a lot of these absurdities fixed.