I was there and thought it was great. Shane's in a no-win situation, really. If he goes up there and does his own thing people will complain, saying he doesn't look, sound or act like Darby. If he goes up there and does a dead-on Darby imitation - complete with the same look, style and mannerisms - people will accuse him of just being an actor pretending to be someone he's not - and you, sir, are no Darby Crash.
I thought he fell somewhere in between - paying respect to Darby's style, while not quite doing a full-blown Darby imitation. I thought he handled it very well. It worked for me.
The band was solid and looked like they were having a great time. Lorna never stopped smiling. Most active crowd I've ever seen at The Black Cat. Too bad there weren't more folks there to see the show. It was maybe 1/2-full.
The guitar thing was weird. I'm still not sure if it was real or not. Fun though.
I saw you there, bearman. Front and center the whole time. Impressive
I hung out for a few minutes after, but I could tell you were planning on hanging out up there for a while, so I took off.