this is a silly argument. Anyone who has watching has seen Lidge, multiple times. come in during tight games (whether with a lead or not) and get blown up, putting the game out of reach.
I'm glad Rizzo can make a decisive move when something is not working out.
Zimmerman always gets screwed when it comes to run support. Wins and losses don't always tell the whole story when it comes to pitching.
Starter's run support:
Stras - 6.9
Gio - 5.9
Zim - 4.9
Jackson - 4.3
Detweiler - 6.0