You can still discuss the "JV 3 no-hitters guaranteed HoF spot" as a hypothetical.... My opinion would be no, at least on the basis of the no-hitters being the overriding factor, since history has shown that no-hitters aren't exactly an indication of career accomplishments..... Virgil Trucks, who once threw 2 no-hitters in a year where his overall record was 5-19, is a good example of the random nature of no-hitters.....