Originally posted by shoot ur shot:
Hoya, did you really think Spielberg was gonna grow some balls all of a sudden and make an unforgiving, nihilistic bloodbath alien pic with a PG-13 rating? So in what way(s) could you have been dissappointed?
(warning, spoilers)
well, first off, this was a pretty nihilistic movie, it was a straight-up horror flick, the scene with the van and the handgun was pretty freaky ... and i liked the sci-fi elements of the premise, the CGI and sound were great, but they didn't focus on the premise or ever really explain what was going on, other than the vapid spielberg bookend narrations ... the movie wasn't about the premise, it was a character study and focused on the human element, which was COMPLETELY pointless ...
where were tom cruise and fam going? what was their motivation? ... the whole point of the movie is following tom cruise and family, and this storyline is so weak and so pointless, it just completely sank the movie ...
a) why the fuck did they shack up with a half-drunk tim robbins for 45 mins?? did they just run out of ideas?
b) who was that woman they ran into on the ferry? what was the point of her? why were they going on the ferry??
c) he said he was going to see their mom in boston, but it seemed sarcastic, to calm down the girl ... was that really their whole motivation throughout the movie? why wasn't boston burned like everything else?
d) the ending was so unrealistic and stupid, just like the rest of the plot
and the heartstring-pulling scenes whacking you over the head with 9/11 references were just way, way, way over the top
i really love apocalyptic and post-apocalyptic flicks, but this one just sucked
the great part about independence day was that it was winking at you the entire time, 'war of the worlds' wasn't, and the plot just absolutely blew, it could have been interesting if they took more of a macro look at the situation