I was totally and utterly blown away. I saw them open for the Pixies at DAR two years ago, but the club was by far a better environment. The setlist was great, the songs were incredibly expanded and reimagined live, and their voices are mindblowingly awesome. The usually sedate 9:30 indie crowd was even way, way into them--hard not to be considering how much energy they brought. I think I did something terrible to my knee bouncing like a madman during "Satellite," but it was worth it. Everything was great, but "Poppy" might have been the surprising highlight. Decent song on record, but the way they carried it off last night made it warmer, fuller, and extremely impressive.
I thought the sound was really well balanced, actually. Where were you that it seemed off? I was down in the front just left of center, maybe 20-30 feet back from the stage.