Originally posted by Shadrach:
We Are Both Carls â?? While I wouldnâ??t be crazy about hitching my wagon to Jon Kitna, I really liked this draft and this overall team. All 4 starting WRâ??s are strong and have great upside, but there isnâ??t much depth at that spot after that. Picking up Betts late in the draft will likely be a steal since thereâ??s no chance Portis stays healthy all season. Overall Grade: B+
I'm not crazy about Kitna, either, as I remember him bumbling through two 8-8 Bengals seasons before Carson Palmer got to play. There was a crazy run on QB's early (5 in the first 2 rounds!), and you could argue every QB other than Peyton was taken a round "too soon" until Round 7. By that point, Kitna, Leinart, and Romo were all close to value. With a Martz offense and 6.02 Ã? 10^23 first-round-pick WR's, Kitna looked good. As for Betts, I'm just happy he was still there after the turnaround since I mis-clicked on Dwayne Bowe (thanks, Outdoor Miners!).
Rock N Roll Outlaws (me) â?? I know this is my team and I will be a little bias, but honestly I think I drafted extremely well and managed to get a little lucky. I have talent, depth and potential at every position. I have two 1000+ yard RBâ??s on the bench and a couple WRâ??s due for big seasons. My only real concern is at the QB position, but I think I have a couple guys that I can switch in and out according to the match ups or who may just blossom into stars. Overall Grade: Iâ??ll leave that up to you.
I'll call it a B++ on the technicality that no draft with Plaxico Burress can get an A, but I think it's a better draft than my B+. With Santonio Holmes on the bench, you're insured against Plaxiglass damage. Your depth at RB might be an issue, as I'm not sure how much Ahman Green has left (esp with the Texans O-line), and both Morency and Taylor have competition. Leinart and/or Losman should have a breakout year, but there are still serviceable QB's on the wire if need be. San Diego's D gets to play Oakland twice, and selecting a kicker (Kasay) late was a good, disciplined pick.
SalParadise â?? Unlike The White Stripes, this is the all-geriatric team.
And with that, my Week 1 opponent renamed to The All-Geriatric Team. Nothing gets me fired up like...beating up old people...