Fascinating. Here's what happened.
I just got through on the phone to an operator. Their system is so jammed they're taking information and will run it later. I am guaranteed tickets, though. Will get a confirmation in email later, and they're mailing tickets.
Very nice ticket agent. Clearly a small ticket company overwhelmed, but they've handled it in a really pleasant manner.
Oh yeah, tickets are $60 each. For two, TOTAL price was $121.25.