I listened to it all the way through the other night twice. It starts out a bit too smooth/yacht rock-ish for me, but I kind of liked the songs near the end. Nothing really jumped out at me and I'm not sure I would put it ahead of any other album. I'd like to hear more of the songs live (they played Walken/Walkin and Impossible Germany) last time at the club.
They are one of my favorite bands and like one of my other favorites, Ted Leo, I am a little disappointed in their new album at first listen, but then again my expectations might have been too high.