The thing about that infamous CYHSY review is a good chuck of it is the author blathering on about how this band got so much attention for their self released CD, without press releases, PR, etc... How is so "refreshing" to a hear a band with out the preceeding hype build up. Not really sure how that garners them a 9.0 as there a plenty of bands out there with remarkable albums without PR folks... You might as well call CYHSY the O.A.R. of indie rock