Whoops I forgot to weigh in, cause I know you were all so anxious to hear my review.
I thought it was great, for what it was. It was literally the comic book coming to life for me (visually). EXCEPT FOR OZYMANDIAS. I called it. He nearly ruined the whole movie for me. Nite Owl was perfect, Rorschach was perfect. I want to be Silhouette for Halloween. I can't even think about the Comedian without swooning...HOLY MOSES, I hated him in the comic (you know, as a "villain"...) but in the movie...RAWR! He can impregnate and shoot me any time. (Current desktop wallpaper is the Comedian lighting his cigar with the flamethrower. I've stopped going to my desktop because it debilitates me each time.) Music was awful. Whoever's responsible for the Hallelujah sex scene should be punished. Don't know why people have a problem with Manhattan though? I mean, it's a "flat" character, what was he expected to be?