Honestly, I don't think this will disappoint. Although the Foo Fighters' last album was rather boring, these three guys all know a thing or two about making good rock music. Dave drumming, to me, means that this won't be another bland FF album. Songs For The Deaf is a kick-ass album, so I think good things will come from this Grohl/Homme collaboration too. To be frank, I could care less about JPJ.
Seth?