Best at F St Location: Jane's Addiction 12/15/88
Worst at F St: Counting Crows 1/19/94
Best at V St location: Tie: Radiohead / Teenage Fanclub 8/12/97
Bryan Ferry Orchestra 11/3/99
Worst at V St: Sugar Ray 7/30/97
Saw Janes at that show, it was a great one. Not sure if it was the best though, but then again I never caught a bad show at the old club.
Think that the best at the old club might have been the Orb. Live drummer and bassist, triphonic (the mono house PA and the stereo back speakers). Otherwise, maybe Husker Du when Bob looked at the video woman all night, or the many Butthole Surfers shows.
New club? Worst is easy. Dispatch. The advantage of working occasionally you see bands you otherwise would miss. THese guys at the time were a MySpace sensation, and they didn't have the chops to pull it off live. THey flubbed notes left and right, no continuity, just bad.
Best, gack so many, the last Spiritualized (HE SMASHED HIS GUITAR!!!!), Sigur Ros (THe drummer is the secret weapon), Love and Rockets, or the Chemical Brothers (Just wow).
More too, but if I said them all I would be here all night.
Crap, Superdrag when GUided couldn't make it, they were amazing.