Not that I am happy when others agree with me...BUT (ha ha) it's cool to see other people "get" the Feelies.
maybe i'm one of the rare people who don't get the feelies, then. i saw them in 2008 in NYC when they opened for Sonic Youth... they were awrite but didn't blow me away. it was their first show together in a while so maybe they were still working out the kinks.
Judging by the setlist, that was a very short show (and outdoors; yes?). Below is a more representative setlist.
1st Set
When Company Comes / Bluer Skies / Egyptian Reggae (Jonathan Richman)
For Now / Invitation / Nobody Knows / Should Be Gone / Let's Go / Again Today
The High Road / On The Roof / Way Down / Seven Days (Bob Dylan)
2nd Set
Deep Fascination / On And On / Higher Ground / The Final Word / Away
Slipping (Into Something) / Doin It Again / Original Love / Time Is Right
Too Far Gone / Raised Eyebrows / Crazy Rhythms
When You Know / Carnival of Sorts (Boxcars) (R.E.M.) / Sooner Or Later
I Wanna Be Your Dog (Stooges) / Fa Cé-La
And that doesn't include the usual VU covers, arcane Doors and Neil Young tunes, and the Stones' "Rocks Off" which they ripped through at one of the 9:30 shows in recent years.
I wholeheartedly encourage you to give them another shot. I mean, how often do hutch, bearman, azaghal, and myself all endorse the same thing?