i agree on shearer, the whole idea is really silly
sam is gone not because newcastle isnt winning. he was fired because the players HE bought were disappointing (enrique, rozenhal, dukes, smith hasnt been great either) or just a disaster (joey barton). he was fired because of negative tactics (playing for a tie at scumderland? seriously). he was fired because of insane team selection. he was fired because he wasnt the chairman's choice in the first place. he was a poor choice by an even poor chairman
jol i think would be a fine choice