I bought BRMC, NPs, and John Vanderslice. I picked up I am Kloot several months ago while in the UK.
BRMC-Obviously a completely different sound. I am really enjoying it right now but I don't know how it will sit after a few more listens. I am excited to see them live, with them hopefully doing half acoustic/half plugged in.
NPs...exactly what you would expect. top notch pop.
John Vanderslice-Good, but not as good as I was hoping for. Although, the song "Trance Manual" is my favorite song of any of the CDs I have bought in the past few months.
I am Kloot...solid, but not special. I swear they are getting worse and worse, though. Their debut was amazing (one of the few discs that I have consistantly listened to for the past five years). They have failed to live up to their promise.