I'll avoid the beer topic because I don't drink, so therefore it doesn't affect me.
I'm glad Seth is clarifying his position in this thread, though I had never doubted him in the first place. As noted in the Reznor post above, a lot of promoters and club owners DO actively participate in the scalping. By not condoning scalping, Seth is at least making some of the process transparent for 9:30 Club shows. Though it'll still occur no matter what safeguards are put into place, it's good to know that one part of the equation is clear.
I've always felt like I've had more than a fair shot at 9:30 Club tickets for any show. The soft-sale almost never sells out instantly, so if I miss a show, it's my fault for not reading Just Announced or paying attention. The shows I do miss (Bloc Party, for example) often fall victim to the Craigslist scalpers, so if I want to go to a show, I know what I have to do.
I'm interested in seeing what bands have facilitated jacking up prices since Reznor claims they are a big part of it.
Couldn't 9:30 Club also require something like the name and last four digits of a credit card on all tickets (to big shows, at least) to prevent scalping? I realize this makes the staff's job a bit tougher, but it can also decrease scalping.