Maharajah is the ony Avery beer I'd go out of my way to have.
i think that's the reason avery has maintained a higher esteem in my mind than they probably deserved - maharaja was the first beer of theirs that i tried, really liked it, so the glow lives on... but it's finally fading. i've had their Reverand (an average quad, good but nothing special), the Hog Heaven (unimpressive, see above), Beast (18% alcohol, tastes like paint thinner, might be good with 2+ years aging), and Karma ale (my second favorite of theirs... nice stuff, but i won't be ordering it a second time given the options i have). batting 1.5/4 is good for a ball player but i expect more from a brewery. it's probably a case of me giving a micro-brewery a little too much leeway.
also, hog heaven has something of a following on a brewing-related board that i follow so i was excited to try it, which only further compounded the disappointment.