It was my first RS show.
The way I see it is that Mick still has "it" both singing, dancing, and harmonica-ing, and the others do not as much have "it" but they are alive and are iconic so they have to play.
So it is not an amazing show "musically."
If Mick, like Paul McCartney, just toured and played RS songs with a killer band, it would be an amazing show musically. As it is, the guitars and drumming sloppy-ish but endearing, and such. I am so glad that I went, and checked this off of the list.
The setlist for me was great. Rocks Off was the fan facebook voted song that I voted for. I am not sure what it is about, I guess stones, rocks, its a whole geology thing, right?
ALSO, and this is most important: word to the wise - keep in touch with your college friends who stay in the concert business and also marry into the family of prominent team-tongue production staff. You may end up with 3rd row tickets and pit-passes to such shows.
Finally, sorry Joe.