Originally posted by Relaxer:
I wouldn't exert to much energy pitying us who "don't get it." I could just as easily say, I feel sorry for anyone who thinks THAT is great.
Hey, did you see the thread on the other new releases that came out yesterday? There's lots of them! Lots and lots and lots of new records, of which Radiohead's is one. If Rainbows was the only record released in 2007, I might be a little disappointed. But it wasn't! Yay! Choice! No need for lockstep agreeance!
I don't understand why people aren't ejaculating over the Gallows, Jay Reatard and Witchcraft records, but I make a big mess over those things all day every day. Do I feel sad? Hell no! Slightly superior and a little hungry? Hell yes!
And besides, when me and my music buddies all agree on the merits of a record, that conversation lasts about a minute and a half. When we disagree on a record, that conversation will drag on for months and months, and to me, that's more fun and stimulating.
I don't mean to imply that something is wrong with not liking it. I just think that music as a unifying factor is part of the fun of it - it is a way of finding some common grounds with people. The ability to share the experience is something that is very powerful. Yes, that can also be true when people vehemently disagree about something - strong reactions generally provide for the best discussions. But finding you have something in common with other people that you might otherwise never identify with? That's a powerful thing, and for me, music is often where I find that commonality.
I think Radiohead is as close as we'll ever get to a band like the Beatles, where the world essentially stopped when they put out a new album. Everybody took an hour and listened to it to see what they thought. Everybody is paying attention.
And again, I don't mean to imply there is a NEED for "lockstep agreeance." But aren't the albums that everybody can admit are great the best? For example, I've said before that I'm not a Velvet Underground fan, but I can admit the importance and greatness of an album like their debut.
I don't know. Maybe it is campy to wish for a piece of art that listeners can unanimously appreciate on some level. But I feel like the one band right now that is capable of that is Radiohead.