Originally posted by Julian, good manners AFICIONADO:
Originally posted by le sonick:
oh wow, so that makes the pumpkins a better band....even IF you believe that it was actually Corgan himself's idea. which is most probably wasnt. try again.
Who said that made the Pumpkins the better band? I simply pointed out that while the entire internet is going, "OMG, unprecedented!" that it's actually quite precedented.
And by all accounts, it was Billy's idea to finish those recording session and release it for free. You think Corgan wanted to release it on a label and Iha stole it from him in the middle of the night, pressed copies, and sent it to places for hosting? Get real.
I seriously don't know where you get half your ad populum ideas from. This ranks right up there with you being "subjected to reunions." :roll: [/b]
lets recap.
1. i say, dont compare the pumpkins to radiohead cause the pumpkins suck.
2. Corgan did beat Radiohead to the "free album online" concept by, oh, 7 years.
so youre comment was not really in response and basically in no way related to my original comment.
i just figured since you replied to my post you were sort of answering it or challenging it.
and then went on some rant about precendence and me not liking reunions, which i dont. and since when is that ad populum anyway.
perhaps only because so many shitty bands have been on reunion tours lately.
just because most people agree doesnt mean they are agreeing just to agree, maybe its really true!
and lastly, i never said that Radiohead has done anything "unprecedented"......other than musically blowing every other band on earth out of the studio...